Pain is the Persuader

Abortion continues to be on a collision course with modern science and medicine.

Earlier this year a prestigious medical group released an analysis that is sure to make more converts to the pro-life side, and I want to make sure you were aware of it.

The American College of Pediatricians (ACPeds) published a position statement entitled, Fetal Pain: What is the Scientific Evidence. It is a comprehensive review of the scientific literature on pain experienced by unborn babies and neonates. Their findings were another milestone victory in our efforts to protect unborn babies from abortion.

Standard medical care for newborns was much different before the late 1980’s when the medical consensus was that neonates didn’t feel pain. But that changed in 1987 with a landmark study published in the New England Journal of Medicine, called “Pain and Its Effects in the Human Neonate and Fetus”.

The research left unsettled questions, however, the evidence it did reveal warranted “re-evaluating the medical standard of care in favor of providing local and general anesthesia during invasive procedures.”

A 1992 study on babies who underwent cardiac surgery was another watershed moment in the medical community. Newborns with congenital heart defects were either given “lighter anesthesia” or “deep anesthesia” during surgical repair. Four of the 15 with lighter anesthesia died before being discharged from the hospital. But all of the 30 babies who received appropriate anesthesia not only survived but did significantly better than babies with less pain control. The research was not replicated for obvious ethical reasons; however, it thankfully impacted the way babies were treated moving forward.

At the heart of the ACPeds analysis, were two different theories to determine if unborn babies perceive pain. (very briefly summarized here)

  • One is that nociception, the physical reaction to noxious stimuli, is possible in preborn children and an indicator that they feel pain.
  • The other according to the International Association for the Study of Pain was that in addition to nociception there must be an “emotional, experiential awareness of pain.”

More details are available in the ACPeds statement.

The ACPeds analysis concluded – as have a growing number of researchers – that the first definition accurately demonstrates unborn babies feel pain at 12 weeks gestation or possibly earlier, and efforts must be made to provide effective anesthesia.

British professor and pain expert Stuart Derbyshire agrees. Dr. Derbyshire supports abortion, has been a consultant for Planned Parenthood, and had previously determined that unborn babies don’t feel pain until twenty-four weeks. Since then he was the lead author in a study that concluded unborn babies can feel pain at 12 weeks.

ACPeds concluded their position statement with words I am convinced will be on the right side of history.

“Medicine’s double standard of acknowledging pain capability in wanted premature babies while denying it in unwanted unborn babies of the same gestational ages is unconscionable.”

Of course, we don’t measure the worth of a child’s life by whether he or she can feel pain in their mothers’ wombs. Still, this new finding is a dramatic milestone in nudging dubious Americans into the pro-life camp.

Few can stomach the concept of a baby experiencing excruciating pain while being unmercifully torn apart in her mother’s womb.

Science and medicine have become effective tools for pro-life education, so let’s make the best use of them to save more lives!

For the babies and their mothers,

Bradley Mattes
President, Life Issues Institute

Life Issues Institute is dedicated to changing hearts and minds of millions of people through education. For 30 years, organizations and individuals around the world have depended upon Life Issues Institute to provide the latest information and effective tools to protect innocent human life from womb to tomb.

Life Issues Institute welcomes comments relevant to columns that are civil, concise, and respectful of other contributors. We do not publish comments with links to other websites or other online material.

One thought on “Pain is the Persuader

  1. There were so many times that I thought the sonograms on the unborn child during an abortion, physically proved that unborn child of God felt pain.
    The “Silent Scream”…the abortionist who saw the unborn child push the needle away during a saline abortion, as he/she was being burned alive. Now there is a video, on youtube, showing a sonogram being done in preparation for an abortion. The child is clearly seen, then a picture of the Crucified Christ appeared in front of the baby. The miracle of life is all I need to know that the unborn child is human, and humans feel physical pain, and the emotion of fear.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *