Well,
thank you all so very much for coming to the White House.
It's my honor to welcome you to the people's house.
I particularly want to honor three folks who I had the honor of meeting earlier:
Joni Tada, Jim Kelly and Steve McDonald. I want to thank you
for your courage, I want to thank you for your wisdom, I want
to thank you for your extraordinary perseverance and faith.
They have triumphed in the face of physical disability and
share a deep commitment to medicine that is practiced ethically
and humanely.
All of
us here today believe in the promise of modern medicine. We're
hopeful about where science may take us. And we're also here
because we believe in the principles of ethical medicine.
As we seek to improve human life, we must
always preserve human dignity. And therefore, we must prevent
human cloning by stopping it before it starts.
I want to welcome Tommy Thompson, who
is the Secretary of Health and Human Services, a man who is
doing a fine job for America. I want to thank members from
the United States Congress, members from both political parties
who are here. I particularly want to thank Senator Brownback
and Senator Landrieu for sponsoring a bill about which I'm
going to speak.
As well,
we've got Senator Frist and Senator Bond and Senator Hutchinson
and Senator Santorum and Congressman Weldon, Stupak, and eventually
Smith
and Kerns. They just don't realize -- thank you all for coming
-- they seem to have forgotten we start things on time here
in the White House.
We live
in a time of tremendous medical progress. A little more than
a year ago, scientists first cracked the human genetic code
-- one of the most important advances in scientific history.
Already, scientists are
developing new diagnostic tools so that each of us can know
our risk of disease and act to prevent them.
One day
soon, precise therapies will be custom made for our own genetic
makeup. We're on the threshold of historic breakthroughs against
AIDS and Alzheimer's disease and cancer and diabetes and heart
disease and Parkinson's disease. And that's incredibly positive.
Our
age may be known to history as the age of genetic medicine,
a time when many of the most feared illnesses were overcome.
Our age
must also be defined by the care and restraint and responsibility
with which we take up these new scientific powers.
Advances in biomedical technology must
never come at the expense of human conscience. As we seek
what is possible, we must always ask what is right, and we
must not forget that even the most noble ends do not justify
any means.
Science
has set before us decisions of immense consequence. We can
pursue medical research with a clear sense of moral purpose
or we can travel without an ethical compass into a world we
could live to regret. Science now presses forward the issue
of human cloning. How we answer the question of human cloning
will place us on one path or the other.
Human cloning is the
laboratory production of individuals who are genetically identical
to another human being. Cloning is achieved by putting the
genetic material from a donor into a woman's egg, which has
had its nucleus removed. As a result, the new or cloned embryo
is an identical copy of only the donor. Human cloning has
moved from science fiction into science.
One biotech
company has already begun producing embryonic human clones
for research purposes. Chinese scientists have derived stem
cells from cloned embryos created by combining human DNA and
rabbit eggs. Others have announced plans to produce cloned
children, despite the fact that laboratory cloning of animals
has lead to spontaneous abortions and terrible, terrible abnormalities.
Human cloning is deeply troubling to me,
and to most Americans. Life is a creation, not a commodity.
Our children are gifts to be loved and protected, not products
to be designed and manufactured. Allowing cloning would be
taking a significant step toward a society in which human
beings are grown for spare body parts, and children are engineered
to custom specifications; and that's not acceptable.
In the
current debate over human cloning, two terms are being used:
reproductive cloning and research cloning. Reproductive cloning
involves creating a cloned embryo and implanting it into a
woman with the goal of creating a child. Fortunately, nearly
every American agrees that this practice should be banned.
Research cloning, on the other hand, involves the creation
of cloned human embryos which are then destroyed to derive
stem cells.
I believe all human cloning is wrong,
and both forms of cloning ought to be banned, for the following
reasons. First, anything other than a total ban on human cloning
would be unethical. Research cloning would contradict the
most fundamental principle of medical ethics, that no human
life should be exploited or extinguished for the benefit of
another.
Yet a law permitting research cloning, while forbidding the
birth of a cloned child, would require the destruction of
nascent human life. Secondly, anything other than a total
ban on human cloning would be virtually impossible to enforce.
Cloned human embryos created for research would be widely
available in laboratories and embryo farms. Once cloned embryos
were available, implantation would take place. Even the tightest
regulations and strict policing would not prevent or detect
the birth of cloned babies.
Third,
the benefits of research cloning are highly speculative. Advocates
of research cloning argue that stem cells obtained from cloned
embryos would be injected into a genetically identical individual
without risk of tissue rejection. But there is evidence, based
on animal studies, that cells derived from cloned embryos
may indeed be rejected.
Yet even
if research cloning were medically effective, every person
who wanted to benefit would need an embryonic clone of his
or her own, to provide the designer tissues. This would create
a massive national market for eggs and egg donors, and exploitation
of women's bodies that we cannot and must not allow.
I stand
firm in my opposition to human cloning. And at the same time,
we will pursue other promising and ethical ways to relieve
suffering through
biotechnology. This year for the first time, federal dollars
will go towards supporting human embryonic stem cell research
consistent with the ethical guidelines I announced last August.
The National
Institutes of Health is also funding a broad range of animal
and human adult stem cell research. Adult stem cells which
do not require the destruction of human embryos and which
yield tissues, which can be transplanted without rejection,
are more versatile that originally thought.
We're
making progress. We're learning more about them. And therapies
developed from adult stem cells are already helping suffering
people.
I support
increasing the research budget of the NIH, and I ask Congress
to join me in that support. And at the same time, I strongly
support a comprehensive law against all human cloning. And
I endorse the bill -- wholeheartedly endorse the bill -- sponsored
by Senator Brownback and Senator Mary Landrieu.
This carefully
drafted bill would ban all human cloning in the United States,
including the cloning of embryos for research. It is nearly
identical to the bipartisan legislation that last year passed
the House of Representatives by more than a 100-vote margin.
It has wide support across the political spectrum, liberals
and conservatives support it, religious people and nonreligious
people support it. Those who are pro-choice and those who
are pro-life support the bill.
This is
a diverse coalition, united by a commitment to prevent the
cloning and exploitation of human beings. It would be a mistake
for the United States Senate to allow any kind of human cloning
to come out of that chamber.
I'm an
incurable optimist about the future of our country. I know
we can achieve great things. We can make the world more peaceful,
we can become a more compassionate nation. We can push the
limits of medical science. I truly believe that we're going
to bring hope and healing to countless lives across the country.
And as we do, I will insist that we always maintain the highest
of ethical standards.
Thank you all for coming. God bless.